0

A Guide to Litigation: What Small Business Owners Need to Know

Owning and operating a small business can be a financially productive venture. However, like other aspects of life, it is not free from its own challenges. Aside from problems that can arise  from the day to day physical demands of the production process or rendering of services, time constraints and other internal and external factors, the possibility of facing litigation is almost as certain as the dawning of a new day!

This write-up seeks to provide answers to the following questions; 

• What steps should I take when my business is facing litigation? 
• Are there important considerations to take note of before engaging in a legal tussle?
• How do I go about the litigation process?
• What measures can I put in place to avoid facing litigation again?

The Basics of Litigation for Small Business Owners

Business litigation involves using the courtroom to settle disputes that arise in the course of running a business. It may also occur as a result of failure to comply with the relevant laws and regulations guiding the operations of a business in a state or locality. No matter how careful and law-abiding you try to be, there is no guarantee that cases of litigation will not arise. This makes it very important for small business owners to understand the basics of litigation to be able to effectively protect their businesses and avoid or minimize anything that predisposes them to litigation.

Common Types of Business Litigation

Small business owners may be faced with varied business litigation issues. Some may be simple, while others may be complex and difficult to recover from. A clear understanding of the various types of business litigation is necessary for identification of possible “legal flashpoints” and how to effectively avoid or handle them.

• Breach of Contract

This occurs when an oral or written agreement is not honored by one party in a business relationship. It is the most common form or ca of business litigation. 

• Breach of Fiduciary Duty

A breach of fiduciary duty occurs when someone fails to act in the best interests of another, often for personal gain. Litigation can arise from breach of fiduciary duty by a business entity.

• Issues from Compliance with Regulatory Measures

When a business falls short of the laws and regulations guiding business activities, it becomes liable to being sued.

• Employer-Employee Rifts 

If adequate attention is not paid to the holistic welfare of the employees of an organization, they may take legal action against their employer. Apart from this, issues on harassment, discrimination and unfair treatment are hotbeds for litigation. In order to avoid this, small business owners must ensure they develop clear workplace policies that are fair and consistent.

• Infringement on the Intellectual Properties of Others

Unauthorized use of the trademarks, copyrights, logos and insignia of other people’s businesses is certain to give rise to court cases.

1. 1. Partnership Disputes:
      Disputes among partners or shareholders can happen over a variety of reasons. Such could be disagreements on profit sharing, business drive or breach of fiduciary duties.
      

• Insurance Coverage Dispute: 

Insurance coverage issues may arise when the wordings of an insurance policy are unclear and burden of evidence is shifted during claims. Professional legal guidance is needed before subscribing to any insurance policy.

Steps to Take When Facing Litigation

Although many small business owners dread litigation, it must be stated that it may not necessarily mean the end of the road for your business if it eventually happens. The effective management of litigation is crucial for the continued survival of your business. When faced with the prospect of litigation, business owners should take proactive steps. These steps include:

1. Consult with an experienced business attorney.
2. Properly document all evidence and materials relating to the case at hand. 
3. Evaluate the cost-benefit analysis of the courtroom proceedings.
4. Consider Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) methods to potentially resolve the conflict more efficiently than through a court battle.

1. Ensure all communications and actions related to the dispute are professionally handled.

Pre-Litigation Preparations

If negotiation with the aggrieved party fails, then adequate preparation for courtroom proceeding is the next course of action. To adequately prepare for litigation, there is the need to: 

1. Understand the Litigation Process: It is important to familiarize yourself with the litigation process and timelines from the initial filing to the discovery phase and ultimately, the trial.This knowledge will help you stay prepared and informed.

2. Gather Evidence: Necessary evidence such as relevant transaction details, tax records, compliance records, witness statements, and any documents relevant to the facts of the case should be systematically compiled and arranged for easy referencing. 

3. Work Closely with Your Attorney: Regular communication and collaboration with your attorney is very necessary as you prepare for courtroom battles. This ensures that you are up to date on the progress of the case and can provide necessary input when required. 
4. Stay Organized and Professional: Keep detailed records of all interactions and maintain professional conduct throughout the process. This can swing the outcome of the case in your favor.

Post-Litigation Considerations

An essential aspect of litigation tussle is post-litigation analysis. This is often overlooked during celebration of a favorable outcome or when counting losses after an undesirable result. It is however necessary to:

1. 1. Evaluate the Outcome: Regardless of the result, reviewing the case can provide insights into areas for improvement in your business practices to avoid future disputes.

   2. Implement Changes: Weak points in your business practices can be plugged by implementing neglected or hitherto unknown policies, updating contracts and reworking the procedures of operation in line with the experiences gained during litigation.           

   3. Keep Litigation Records: Records of the litigation process should be properly kept. It can serve for reference if similar cases occur in the future.
      

• Rebuild Trust: Certainly, courtroom face-off causes strained business relationships. However, if such a relationship is still desired, you will need to seek effective means of readjusting your business practices to rebuild trust and give the right message that issues of concern are being addressed.
  

• Retrain Employees: Lessons learned during litigation should be inserted into the training sessions of your employee. This will help them to be aware of actions that can lead to litigation and how to avoid them.
  

• Reflect and Adapt: When necessary, the experience gained from the litigation should be used to rework the overall business strategy of the organization with focus on risk reduction while not sacrificing operational efficiency. 

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, understanding business litigation and its various types is essential for small business owners to effectively manage or minimize the risk  of legal challenges. By familiarizing themselves with the litigation process, from the initial consultation with a lawyer to the final resolution, business owners can make informed decisions that protect their interests. 

Prioritizing proactive measures, such as thorough documentation and collaboration with a legal professional during the pre-litigation stage, may help to swing the courtroom process in the desired direction.

Post-litigation evaluation is also critical for assimilation of the lesson learned to avoid a repeat of the mistakes made and be in a better position to effectively manage other issues that may occur in the future. Making necessary changes to the business structure such as creating an LLC or other business structures can help reduce losses from litigation and enforce the need for well-structured legal support.